Matthew 19:1-12; Malachi 2:14-16Matthew 19 is an account of a question-answer exchange with Jesus. First, the Pharisees, as they often did, try to trap him in a theological debate with a loaded question. This time, they ask him about divorce.
In verse 3, the Pharisees ask, "Is it lawful to divorce one's wife for any cause?" The heart of the question goes to a dispute among Jewish religious leaders of the day. The school of Shammai held that divorce was only permissible due to adultery or infidelity; in fact, it was required by Jewish law in those cases. The school of Hillel believed that men could divorce their wives indiscriminately.
Jesus' first answer is recorded in verses 4-6. His answer is, as is often the case, to not answer an entrapping question directly, but to raise the standard of the premise on which the issue rests.
He directs the Pharisees all they way back to Genesis! He quotes from Genesis 1:27, 5:2, and 2:24, where Scripture says plainly that God created people as male and female so that "a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh." Then he makes a bold statement, "What therefore God has joined together let not man separate." His first response is to say, "Hey! You are missing the point. God intended marriage to be a lifelong covenant from the beginning."
So, of course, the Pharisees try again. This time they use sources, and quote Moses in Deuteronomy 24:1-4, and ask, "Why did Moses command divorce?" Jesus corrects them again, by saying no one ever commanded divorce, merely allowed it, because of "hardness of heart". Is this to say Jesus is condoning "irreconcilable difference" divorces? Not at all! The "hardness of heart" he is referring to is sin itself. Jesus says, "From the beginning it was not so." But, since man has fallen and is now prone to sin, there will arise tragic circumstances in which sin has irretrievably damaged marriages. Jesus says you should consider divorce in such cases (of sexual immorality) a provision of God's grace.
Malachi 2:14-16 may help us see why Jesus took such a staunch position when he was questioned about divorced. Malachi is the only book besides Proverbs that uses the word "covenant" to describe marriage. In the book of Malachi, it is made clear that covenants involve 4 conditions: a covenant is 1) a relationship with 2) a nonrelative that 3) involves obligations and 4) is established through an oath or vow. Malachi goes out of his way to refer to marriage as a covenant, in the same way he refers to the Levitical covenant, the covenant of "our fathers" with the Lord, and is the only prophet to use the phrase "messenger of the covenant" in reference to John the Baptist, who, of course, prepares the way for Christ.
Also, Malachi 2:15 refers to the work of the Spirit in fusing the bonds of marriage. The same idea of two becoming one is made clear here, and we see that God as given a portion of His Spirit in establishing the covenant between husband and wife upon their vows.
It has been stated that verse 16 is perhaps the most difficult to translate in all of the Bible. Whether it says "God hates divorce" or "the man who does not love his wife," the indication is that the marriage covenant is not something that is ended lightly. The phrase is translated "does not love" in the ESV is done so because it literally means "to cease to love" or to "love less." Interestingly, the most popular reason for divorce in Jesus' day, as well as in our day, is simply unhappiness or "loss of love."
I am inspired by Ephesians 5:22-33 and 1 John 4:7-12 that tell us the true meaning of love, and that when we learn to love as Christ has demonstrated to us, we understand that it is unconditional and sacrificial. In our society it is easy to claim that the Bible's position on divorce is stiff or extreme. But I think this standard is greatly upheld in the same way Jesus answered the Pharisees: that we shouldn't lose sight of God's intention and His standard for our marriages, and that even though we live in a fallen world, we have the gifts of God's Word to guide us and the Christ's love to compel us. And that is the gospel. Praise be to God that we have forgiveness through Jesus Christ, and since we have been saved through Him we can seek to live in ways that please God and that are testimonies to the world of the gospel.



